p4k No 12: Father John Misty – I Love You, HoneybearPosted: February 14, 2016
Had I ever heard of them before: yes, yes, indie darling used to be a drummer in the Fleet Foxes (terrible band – terrible band name)
Reductive First Impression: I’m not going to be the first to say this and won’t be the last: Father John Misty’s a jerk.
Ok, so he is a witty, erudite, quotable lyricist but the tone that comes across the whole time is “I’m a clever asshole and mostly everything’s terrible.” I couldn’t help but compare him to The Mountain Goats, who’s lyrics are equally clever but also evocative and have some empathy.
Musically the songs are… quite good. I can see why he used to be in Fleet Foxes and as I said, I dislike Fleet Foxes.
To quote Modest Mouse (another excellent lyricist) on Bukowski, “God, who’d want to be such an asshole?”
Will I listen to it again: Probably and I’ll probably proclaim its genius and love his “character”.